Miller
Verified Member
Dippy Dave? Give me a break!!!!!! K
yeah, that's just loony steve.....
Dippy Dave? Give me a break!!!!!! K
Had James Walden been nominated and supported by others, he would have been given consideration on one or more of our One Pocket ballots. You must have overlooked him lol. But Lifetime Pool in Action is still the One Pocket Hall of Fame -- that is not a joke Steve.
Regarding the other names you nominated, here are my thoughts:
- Tony Chohan -- probably does not meet the 20 year threshold. I met him in 2004 and he was a good young player but still emerging.
- Richie Richeson -- he probably does qualify, although as much as I respect him, he is a little below the top tier players wouldn't you say?
- “Hamburger” Pete Porter -- I don't know him
- Paul Bruseloff -- we have had him on the short list for lifetime pool in action. He told me he doesn't want the spotlight essentially. If you can talk him into coming and accepting the award he could jump back up to the top of the short list.
- Charles Cook -- Bucktooth -- yes he would fit given the action element
- Sammy Blumenthal -- his name has probably come up in the past, but how much was One Pocket his main game? I thought it was Snooker
- Marcel Camp -- perennial legacy candidate who by all accounts was an ambassador for the game; just tough to get traction and he had peers that are already in that our members apparently felt were a little better qualified. Not every really good candidate gets in.
- “Dippy” Dave Peat -- probably does not meet the 20 year threshold
- Alex Pagulayan -- great candidate and 2020 this year he is indeed eligible!
- Dennis Orcullo -- I doubt meets the 20 year threshold
- James Leone -- Is he the owner of Buffalo's? I don't know much about him but his room sure gets high marks!
Dippy Dave? Give me a break!!!!!! K
yeah, that's just loony steve.....
Marcel Camp (deceased)– One of the early great One Pocket players credited with influencing the rise in One Pocket in the years before Johnston City. Camp was a solid all around player and action legend.If we have any Hall of Famers that could give us a narrative on Marcel Camp; his skills, his pedigree, who he beat that would be very helpful in determining his nomination.
This is an issue for me, since I am responsible for writing up a bio and trying to locate a family descendant to accept the honor.If we have any Hall of Famers that could give us a narrative on Marcel Camp; his skills, his pedigree, who he beat that would be very helpful in determining his nomination.
That's just you trying to do that Steve. I tried to be understated in rolling with your half serious/half ridiculous/ plus you also threw in an extra disdainful twist to your above nomination post. I guess my attempt to lighten my reply didn't work with you. I appreciate the serious part of your nomination post for sure, but not so much the other parts because that is you trying to turn something that really means a lot into "a half ass joke". There is no need for that.I don’t know why you brought up the (lol), what’s funny about it? James was the top dog gambling at one pocket for quite a while.
No, I never overlooked James as a nomination LOL matter of fact I know I brought him up often LOL
I brought up Marcel Camp every year LOL
Look back at all the threads started every year, people get on and nominate people that are already in WTF! LOL
So just put someone in at some category just to put them in??? LOL
That’s why I added some stupid names in with my legitimate ones, looks like it’s going to turn into a half ass joke instead of really meaning something.
That's just you trying to do that Steve. I tried to be understated in rolling with your half serious/half ridiculous/ plus you also threw in an extra disdainful twist to your above nomination post. I guess my attempt to lighten my reply didn't work with you. I appreciate the serious part of your nomination post for sure, but not so much the other parts because that is you trying to turn something that really means a lot into "a half ass joke". There is no need for that.
Joe, lots of the old timers raved about Camp. I looked through a couple of Steve's interviews, and here are a few comments about Camp's high level play:If we have any Hall of Famers that could give us a narrative on Marcel Camp; his skills, his pedigree, who he beat that would be very helpful in determining his nomination.
DocJoe, lots of the old timers raved about Camp. I looked through a couple of Steve's interviews, and here are a few comments about Camp's high level play:
"OnePocket.org: Did you get connected with a particular player at that point to learn the game?
Danny DiLiberto: I watched. The closest I had to learning from someone was with Marcel Camp in Florida. He was a great player of the old days, and he played every game well. I learned a lot from him, but it was mostly from watching and noting what he did, and then I added stuff. …"
----------------------------
"OnePocket.org: How about Marcel Camp, did you ever play him?
Eddie Taylor: Oh I knew Marcel real well. He came to my hometown and put on a show, and he was the US Snooker Champion at that time, and I played him an exhibition. We played two out of three and he beat me of course. At that time, Snooker was pretty much my best game other than Banks."
----------------------------
From Fred Bentivegna’s book, The “Encyclopedia” of Pool Hustlers: “[Marcel] Camp left a lifetime legacy of world class one pocket. For many years he played as well as anybody. I hve a very short list of players who I think really knew how to play the game of one pocket correctly. Camp is near the top of that list. I learned plenty just watching him. He knew the game of one pocket as well as anybody alive...”
-----------------------------
I also recall Squirrel Carpenter praising Camp's 1P abilities, but I can't recall where it was. I don't think that Squirrel and Steve ever got together for an interview.
~Doc
I do really think steve boothe would be a great addition to hall of fame. I think alex pagulayan is a shoe in I also like the idea of john henderson not only for years of playing high level one pocket but the work he has done to promote pool for his entire life.