CaliRed said:
Artie,
you obviously have strong opinions on who was the best and they don't include Efren.
You have to agree though... Efren has won everything in sight for the last 20 years on a regular basis. That's pretty strong I would think. That's a long time to continue to be at the top.
Here he is.. 57 and still winning championships. In onepocket and rotation games, even in bank pool he's finishing high.
He might not play the "right" way to you, but you have to agree however he plays, it has what it takes to win against all the others that play more the "right" way.
Another question.... you say Willie Mosconi was the 2nd best all around player.. I've never heard anyone mention that. Was he that strong at bank pool and onepocket? We all know he can run balls like a madman.
When these questions are brought up.. .it's very subjective, so there will never be a person that all people agree on, and there is no right or wrong answer.
Eferine belomgs in with all the greatest players. And You say different things that I say.
I said Eferine is one off the greatest. In certain games. And he played a lot off games great.
I always have said that Eferine is great. And nobody can can denie that.
And you talk about rotation. Well nobody in America played it. So what are you talking abouta game we didnt play. And Macy Shots we sisnt shoot them and learn them.
Pick out the main pool games and was Eferine the best at any off them. I would say no. Because thier are other people who played over him. Like Bank pool Sratight pool Three coushion.
The games you can talk about are Nineball. and one pocket. Nine ball was he the best.
I would say its between 5 players. One pocket is the other game. was he the best.
I would say no. And this is when everyone played thier best.And then we would have too talk about 5 by 10 tables. Because thats what they played on a lot back then.
With different balls. And Equipment. And thats it. Snooker and 3 coushion he was not a champion.
Eferine played inalmost more tournemets then anybody. If it was not for the tournements who would no him? Tournements made all these players. And put them on the map.
I went through this with a person. Whatever works and you win with it. Keep doing it that way.
It doesnt matter if it is wright or wrong. Just a different way off doing it.
If it works dont change to something that is correct and doesnt work for you.
Eferine Strickland and Buddy and whimpy and Mosconie have Extrordinary. Ability and talant.
And Eferine in executhing is in the top 3. And He would be my choice for exicuting a shot. And with position.
And People dont realize howe strong that is. The name off the game is roo make balls. And If someone doest miss. Howe are you going too win.
Thats what Ederine does better then the rest. And that is why he wins. Because off his great shooting ability.
Not by out smarthing his opponent. His Knowledge part off the game is highly over rayted. Just look at his games and matches.
Does Eferine have more accurate fier power then. Whimpy Worst Ronnie Bugs Taylor. I would say Eferine has more ability. And he shoots more accurate.
What about mistakes. Yes he makes more mistakes then Buddy Whimpy Taylor. On mistakes he is on the same levele with Ronnie Bugs and Cornbread.
And Eferines control. is better then all these players. Excepte Whimpy and worst. But I think his control off the cue ball was better too.
I would pick players over him in that catagory. But only a few.
Eferine plaed in more pool tournemets then all the old great players put together. Is that clear enough.
To make a statement Eferine doesnt play wright. Is not a correct statement.
If you wi you are playing wright. And if he was playing wrong he wouldnt win.
He makes some weak choices. For whatever reason he does it.
He playes and wins with what he knowes and does it. Whatever he does he does not make too meny mistakes.
Because he execuits everything he shoots. And that is his greatness. Its not about playing the wright way.
But what works for you. And if Eferine would have learned. the correct way too play. And all the things he could have learned and done.
Nobody could have touchet him.
If I could have shot and had the ability that Eferine had. And shot macy shots. And learned some off the things he does and no.
I could have given any champion 8 to 6.
I have said this ment times. If you play the whole game correctly. And mistake free. Your oponent should not get a ball.
And to have that great ability. It would have been like Joe Louis fighting middle wieghts.
And even today. If I could shot and execuite like Eferin or Shane or Alex. Or Eral.
All these players today could get a ball or two. And it would be no contest.
Do you realize howe strong it is too shot like that and get the first shot?
Thats wht it never bothered me giving up the breack too champions.
Becaue I no what too do. Howe bad would eferine beat these players. If he got the first shot with his great shooting ability.
And all my moves and shots would be so much stronger. Because I could back them up with great shooting.
And shooting like that I can play different to get different shots. Witch I could not do. Because off howe I bankt and shot.
Let Eferine shoot and bank like I did. See howe meny players he beats whith my ability. I played with.
Things are always easier if you have that great ability and talent.
Willie Mosconie was one off the greatest. He played great straight pool and great nineball. and eight ball. And he played world champion three coushion billiards.
He played decient bamks too.Nicky vach the Fuscos and all the players who seen willy play nine ball. and theseother games.
Said he was great at all games.
And if he would have learned too play one pocket the correct way. He could have been the greatest ever in life.
But he didnt. And if he was around in todays generation. He would have played all thse games way better . Because off all the tournemets. And pool knowledge that is on the interner.
And he was the classest player. I ever seen put on a exabition. Nobody was in his class. And he new howe to macy and do all kinds off trick shots.
And with all thse trick shot tournements who knowes howe great he would have been.
And Mike Macy is the greatest trick shooter ever in life.
And thier is no telling howe great will would have been. If he played in todays generation.
And he had too much talent and ability. To learn any game. And he played great on 4 and a half by nines and five by tens.
And Willie if he learned one pocket. Would have past Eferine up. Because of his knowledge.
Bur he played when toudnements were very view. And that is another reason you cannot compaire players from different generations.
He is truly i a class with the elite. Everything Willie did was great. And I belive if Willie would have played nineball in all these tournements. He would have wone meny off them.
He had ability knowledge and a strong attitude to win. And players like that are hard too beat.
But when you say a player wasthe best you cannot make it for all pool games. Because that is not true.
I give people what they desirve. And what I see. If I didnt see them play . I have no commente.
Howe can you say someone is the best or not the best if you havant seen them play.
And you have too know what you are looking at. And be qualified too make a decision.
One person over all the others. And did you see all these other people play. Thier best game?
Most people go by what they hir.And if you never seen someone play. Howe can you give a opinion on that person?
I hope I clarified all off this. I put it out thier for everyone. And I no that further down they line it will come up again.
And if one player plated in 200 hundred tournemets. And thee other player in a few or none.
Howe can you pick one player over another. The compairison is incorrect. And cannot be compaierd.
They only way too prove it is. Both players have too play each other meny times in thier prime.
And thier are no taps or DVD for the older players. Because this is all new.
And we all no Willy Mosconie was the Babe Ruth of Straight pool. And he dominated they game.
In a time when thier were meny great straight pool players. Look at the one pocket field wright nowe today.
It looks pretty weak too me. Especialy in the thinking department. Everyone is a shooter.
Because off the tournements. And rules. Eferine is a great player and worrier and he won a lot off tournements.
WAs he the best? He would not be my choice. Does he belong up thier with the top 5 . Yes he does.
And the same in nine ball. THe other games. He is not in the top 5 or 10.