more 2 cents
if we are going to let the breaker have a 3rd break
if he makes one
then we need to make THIS rule official
that if you make a ball AND scratch at the same time on your break
THE BALL GETS SPOTTED
YOU OWE ONE
AND YOU OPPONENT HAS BALL IN HAND BEHIND THE HEAD STRING
how can we let someone break again if they scratch on the break ?????
any other rule is uncivilized .......I believe this method of solving the scratch had the most consensus, BIH/BTL -1.